Home Bunion Surgery Ankle Replacement Achilles Repair Plantar Fasciitis Blog Providers
Patient Guides

How to Choose a Foot and Ankle Surgeon: 7 Questions to Ask

Choosing the right foot surgeon impacts your outcome more than any other factor. Ask these 7 questions before scheduling surgery with a podiatrist or orthopedic surgeon.

Why Your Surgeon Choice Matters Most

Study after study shows that surgeon experience and volume is the single biggest predictor of surgical outcomes — for bunion surgery, ankle replacement, Achilles repair, and virtually every foot and ankle procedure.

A high-volume surgeon performing 100+ bunion surgeries per year will statistically have better outcomes, fewer complications, and lower revision rates than a surgeon performing 10 per year.

7 Questions to Ask

1. Are you board-certified? Look for ABFAS (podiatrists) or ABOS (orthopedic surgeons). Board certification means they passed rigorous exams proving competence.

2. How many of this procedure do you perform per year? The most important question. Higher volume = better outcomes. For bunion surgery, look for 50+. For ankle replacement, look for 20+.

3. What is your complication rate? A good surgeon will know their numbers and share them. Infection rates, revision rates, and nerve injury rates should all be tracked.

4. What technique do you recommend and why? A skilled surgeon should explain options (traditional vs MIS for bunions, open vs percutaneous for Achilles) and why they recommend one for YOUR case.

5. What does recovery look like? Get specific timelines: when can you drive, walk in regular shoes, return to work, exercise?

6. What are the risks specific to my case? Every patient has unique risk factors. Your surgeon should address your specific anatomy, medical history, and goals.

7. Can I see before and after photos or patient outcomes? Experienced surgeons often have portfolios of results. This is especially important for bunion surgery where cosmetic outcome matters.

Red Flags to Watch For

  • Surgeon doesn't know their complication rates or is unwilling to share
  • Recommends surgery without trying conservative treatment first (for non-emergency conditions)
  • Only offers one technique and dismisses alternatives
  • Seems rushed during consultation — doesn't answer questions thoroughly
  • Has very few reviews or consistently negative patient feedback
  • Cannot explain why surgery is necessary in clear, non-technical terms

Getting a Second Opinion

  • Ankle replacement vs fusion decisions
  • Complex bunion or flatfoot reconstruction
  • Any revision surgery
  • Cases where the first surgeon seems uncertain

Many insurance plans cover second opinions at no extra cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I see a podiatrist or orthopedic surgeon?
Both can be excellent. Choose based on the individual surgeon's experience with YOUR specific condition. A podiatrist who does 200 bunion surgeries/year may be better than an orthopedist who does 20.
How do I verify a surgeon's credentials?
Check ABFAS.org (podiatrists) or ABOS.org (orthopedic surgeons) for board certification status. State medical boards list any disciplinary actions.
Is it worth traveling for a specialist?
For complex procedures like ankle replacement, yes. Outcomes are so volume-dependent that traveling to see a high-volume specialist is worth it. For routine bunion surgery, local high-volume surgeons are fine.
What if I don't click with my surgeon?
Trust your instinct. You should feel heard, respected, and confident. If not, see someone else. You're choosing a surgical partner — the relationship matters.

Find Specialists Near You

Ready to Find a Specialist?

Search 82,023 foot specialists across 50 states.

Find Specialists Browse All Procedures